Question #3: Patient Autonomy; Readings: Ackerman, “Why Doctors Should Intervene.” (10 points)
A doctor is treating two patients who have both tested positive for COVID-19. Patient A appears to understand his diagnosis and has very mild symptoms, such as a fever, tiredness and a dry cough. Patient B has a more severe case and is experiencing difficulty breathing. Patient B is also very confused and seems not to understand the severity of his condition. Both patients refuse to follow the doctors recommended treatments.
According to Ackerman, do both Patient A and Patient B have autonomy? Be sure to explain which of Ackerman’s arguments support your answer.
According to Ackerman, should the doctor respect both patients’ refusals of treatment? Be sure to explain which of Ackerman’s arguments support your answer.
In your own opinion, do you think that both patients have autonomy? Be sure to provide your own arguments to support your answer.
In your own opinion, if you were the doctor, would you respect both patients’ refusal of treatment? Be sure to provide your own arguments to support your answer.